Brian Sumpter Sports Football,High school football,Middletown High School Middletown’s season ends with 37-20 loss

Middletown’s season ends with 37-20 loss

Middletown’s season ends with 37-20 loss post thumbnail image

St. Vincent dominates during North Coast Section Division 5 first-round playoff game

By Brian Sumpter

Lake County Sports on Facebook

PETALUMA >> It became all too apparent all too soon that the Middletown Mustangs were up against a playoff opponent the likes of which they hadn’t faced this season or perhaps in any other postseason.

The St. Vincent Mustangs, state champions in 2023 and 2024, a team with huge offensive and defensive lines and no shortage of offensive weapons, did something to Middletown that was a first for 2026, and even harder to imagine when you factor in Middletown’s successful postseason run just a year ago when it barely missed a trip to the state championship game.  St. Vincent absolutely and positively neutralized the Mustangs’ running attack of Tyler Galamay and Johnny Finney en route to a 37-20 victory in the opening round of the North Coast Section Division 5 playoffs Saturday afternoon in Petaluma.

And that final score is misleading given that all three of Middletown’s scores – one in the third quarter and two in the fourth quarter – came against a mixture of starter or reserves in third quarter or just reserves in the fourth. The Petaluma-based Mustangs scored the game’s first 30 points and led 37-6 at one point before Middletown closed the gap a bit.

Most impressive, St. Vincent’s defense held Middletown without a first down until the 6:37 mark of the second quarter. A Middletown offense that had averaged 37.7 points a game during the regular season, that had torn up opposing defenses with its double-barreled running attack of Galamay-Finney, couldn’t budge the St. Vincent defense that allowed only a few running plays of longer than three yards until the fourth quarter. The longest in the first three quarters was just eight yards.

“Call it delusional, but we thought we were going to be able to compete with these guys,” Middletown head coach Kurtis Woodard said. “They are a dynasty, a powerhouse.”

While St. Vincent (5-6) was getting healthy with the return of some key players, the critical link in the Middletown (8-3) defense, middle linebacker Ryan Halveson was hobbled by an ankle injury and wasn’t able to play at anything approaching 100 percent. A healthy Halverson certainly would have helped because St. Vincent had great success running up the middle, especially running back Levi Kennedy, who rolled up 119 yards and 12 carries, including touchdown runs of 1, 7 and 5 yards, all attained in the first three quarters.

“He did what he could basically playing on one leg, so much respect to him,” Woodard said of Halverson.

Both teams went three-and-out on their first possession, but St. Vincent’s offense quickly found its stride. On St. Vincent’s second possession, the team moved 71 yards in just four plays, including back-to-back runs of 18 and 38 yards by Kennedy. A 14-yard pass from Willy Pedersen to Barrett Chaput made it 6-0.

Another long St. Vincent drive on its next possession, this one covering 74 yards, used 12 plays. It used up the final few minutes of the first quarter and just over a minute of the second quarter before Kennedy scored on a 1-yard run. Middletown’s defense had opportunities to snuff out the drive early on, but Pedersen went from almost being sacked to scrambling for a 17-yard gain on a third-and-12 play. And St. Vincent also converted on a fourth-and-one play when Kennedy broke free for 18 yards. Kennedy burned the Middletown defense against on a third-and-five from the Middletown 27-yard-line, weaving his way through defenders for a 13-yard gain.

“They beat us up and down and did whatever they wanted,” Woodard said.

Middletown lost a fumble on its next possession, the first of our turnovers for the Mustangs, and St. Vincent almost immediately cashed in, moving 24 yards in three plays, with George McConnell scoring on a 4-yard run with 7:24 left in the first half.

The Mustangs were on the move on their next possession, picking up their first two first downs of the game, the second one on a 46-yard pass from Jamisen Jackson to Galamay that put the ball at the St. Vincent 24, but things bogged down after that. The next three plays – a run and two passes – netted only three yards, and Jamisen’s fourth-and-seven pass, which was thrown up for grabs, cam down in the arms of St. Vincent’s Chaput.

Middletown’s defense did force a punt that let the Mustangs with great field position at the St. Vincent 47 and still plenty of time left, but Middletown unraveled. After a run was stopped for a two-yard loss, the Mustangs were called for a false-start penalty, then Jackson was sacked for an 11-yard loss. After a five-yard penalty on St. Vincent, Galamay was dropped for a three-yard loss on third-and-23, and the Mustangs had to punt.

While the Mustangs were still technically in the game trailing 18-0 at halftime, it was a mirage. Middletown received the second-half kickoff only to fumble the ball away two plays in. St. Vincent took over at the Middletown 41 and had a 24-0 lead five plays later on a Kennedy seven-yard run. Again, Middletown’s defense had a chance to stop St. Vincent on a fourth-down play, but Pederson broke loose for a 25-yard run on fourth-and-one.

It was at that point Woodard said he knew the Mustangs were in big, big trouble.

“We were four TDs down and that’s an uphill climb all the way,” Woodard said. “Once they got momentum, they were hard to stop. It just wasn’t happening for us today.”

Pretty much in desperation mode by this point, Middletown went for a fourth-and-10 from its own 35-yard-line on its next possession, but Jamisen was sacked for a seven-yard loss.

St. Vincent had a 30-0 lead three plays later following completions of 12 and 11 yards and Kennedy’s five-yard touchdown run.

With the Petaluma-based Mustangs subbing in some reserves, Middletown finally broke up the shutout on its next possession, a 42-yard pass from Jackson to Colton Karp, who was wide open down the middle, making it 30-6.

However, St. Vincent was on the move again by quarter’s end and Gianni Enriquez scored on a 1-yard run three plays into the fourth quarter to make it 37-6.

Middletown gave its fans something to feel good about in the fourth quarter when Jackson connected with Finney on a 7-yard touchdown pass that was set up by a 40-yard pass from Jackson to Karp, and Galamay’s 66-yard touchdown run down the Middletown sideline in 3:05 left to play, that following a Middletown fumble recovery.

Galamay’s long run up to that point was just six yards and he finished with 75 overall, giving him 1,221 for the season. Finney had just 17 yards on six carries.

St. Vincent rolled up a season-best 242 yards rushing led by Kennedy. The Petaluma team had another 132 through the air.

“Whether you lose by one or 17 points, it still hurts,” Woodard said of the end of his second season as Middletown’s head coach.

Woodard had nothing but praise for the seniors on the team who were playing their final game for Middletown.

“Every single one of them, I appreciate how hard they’ve worked,” Woodard said. “Today didn’t go our way but thank you for all your work. This was a great group of kids.”

Looking forward to next season, Woodard said the 2027 Mustangs will be back in the weight room in January and there is plenty of talent returning and moving up from the junior varsity squad. The rest is up to the Middletown players.

“This year’s junior class has a chance to be the best class that has ever come through Middletown if they live up to their potential,” Woodard said. “If they can rally the troops next year, we will be successful.”

St. Vincent, the No. 4 seed to Middletown’s No. 5 this year, travels to No. 1 seed Ferndale (10-1) next Saturday in a rematch of last year’s Division 5 semifinal won by Ferndale.

GAME NOTES: Middletown had five runs for no gain or losses in the first half … Jackson had a particularly tough day, being sacked three times, intercepted twice and going 7-for-16 for 144 yards and two touchdowns … Middletown had just 23 yards rushing through three quarters. The Mustangs finished with 106 overall … It was the first meeting between the formal North Central League II rivals since the 2018 playoffs when Middletown won 48-0 at Middletown … St. Vincent went 0-5 in the Redwood Empire Adobe League this season, but those losses came to Cardinal Newman (42-7), Marin Catholic (29-0), Windsor (35-21), American Canyon (49-46) and San Marin (21-20 in overtime).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Post